appeals.esq

Civil · Criminal · Immigration

Appeals in New York, New Jersey, Florida and Texas

Which court hears the appeal: the appellate courts of each state, the federal courts of appeals above them, and the immigration appeal system.

State and federal courts

Where an appeal goes

Civil and criminal appeals in each state, from the first appeal to the state’s highest court, and the federal court of appeals for the state.

New York

Appellate Division → Court of Appeals

Appeals court
Appellate Division of the Supreme Court: four courts, one for each Judicial Department. Civil and criminal appeals.
Appeals from local courts
City, town, village and district courts and the New York City Civil and Criminal Courts: Appellate Term in the First and Second Departments, County Court in the Third and Fourth.
Highest court
Court of Appeals
Federal appeals
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
New Jersey

Appellate Division → Supreme Court

Appeals court
Appellate Division of the Superior Court: appeals from the trial courts, the Tax Court and state agencies.
Highest court
Supreme Court of New Jersey
Federal appeals
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
Florida

District Courts of Appeal → Supreme Court

Appeals courts
Six District Courts of Appeal, First through Sixth.
Highest court
Supreme Court of Florida
Federal appeals
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Texas

Courts of Appeals → Supreme Court or Court of Criminal Appeals

Appeals courts
First through Fourteenth Courts of Appeals, each for its own region: civil and criminal appeals.
Statewide
Fifteenth Court of Appeals: civil appeals in most cases brought by or against the State and its agencies, and appeals from the Texas Business Court.
Highest courts
Supreme Court of Texas for civil and juvenile cases; Court of Criminal Appeals for criminal cases, including direct appeals of death sentences.
Federal appeals
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Federal agencies and courts

Immigration appeals

Immigration cases are federal: the route is the same in all four states until a case reaches a federal court of appeals.

Immigration judge decisions

Appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), part of the U.S. Department of Justice.

USCIS denials

Many can be appealed to the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO). Some, including denials of family-based visa petitions, go to the BIA instead. Not every denial can be appealed.

Orders of removal

Reviewed by a petition for review in the federal court of appeals for the circuit where the immigration judge completed the proceedings: for immigration courts in New York, the Second Circuit; New Jersey, the Third; Florida, the Eleventh; Texas, the Fifth.

8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(2)